'Something doctor'

27 Feb 09

Dr Heena Patel

As I write this first piece for FIH, I remember my guru’s first instructions to my husband and I over 20years ago, 'now you are doctors of the body, become doctors of the soul’. In day-to-day General Practice this is as important, as it is in our broader outlook when we address the quality of care we deliver. I feel this is as relevant today as at the inception of the NHS.

Knowledge pertaining to the soul is given in the Vedas - ancient texts from India. Veda means ‘working knowledge’ i.e. that which works is Veda.  There are many branches to Veda, for e.g. medicinal knowledge that works to ensure longevity is called Ayur Veda. 

Veda explains the soul, or the atma as the life giving force. Veda also gives fundamental knowledge about how to scrutinisingly understand the body, mind and soul divide to optimise disease resolution. The General Practitioner is in a position to integrate different aspects of all knowledge available to him or her for the overall benefit of the patient whose needs must remain at the core of the caring process at all times.

Suzy, my last patient on New Year’s Eve gave me a hug, and a smile through her tears as she left. In her fist she clutched my email address, which she said would be her anchor in times of ‘need’.  She had resigned herself to sailing away from the British Isles working once more in a casino on a cruiser set for the Far East.

Suzy reckoned she had no prospects of a job nearer to home and without income, faced homelessness. She came from a broken family, there was nowhere else for her to go, and she had not a penny in savings. The cruiser job will ‘at least provide me a roof with food’ and this time ‘I’ll try and save money’. The cruiser would bring back memories though. Memories so distressing that Suzy would refuse to allow our 5th year medical student to sit in on her consultation with me.

She sobbed as she related how the trust and hopes she had carefully placed in the ‘man of her dreams’ whom she met on her previous cruiser job had turned out to be unfounded.  The loss of face, and faith she experienced threatened her previously fragile mental health.

Despite a past medical history of self-harm, she had seriously addressed her own health. As she was a young hypertensive, she took regular exercise, was careful about her diet, alcohol intake, and had successfully stopped smoking. This had not been easy in the working environment of a cruiser casino.

Now Suzy felt dreadfully dejected, hopeless, worthless and scarred. Her previous experience told her that antidepressants or sleeping pills offered no real or long-term solutions, but she needed ‘something doctor’.

Suzy had heard of my interest in the science of the soul, and  I explained to her that although her pains were so acute, and her mind so anguished and her life so lonely there was still knowledge available from the Vedas that she could utilize to find her way out. She was immediately interested, commenting that she felt a sense of peace whenever she came.

Over the next two consultations, Suzy grasped surprisingly quickly, and to her great advantage the basic Vedic teachings that ‘we are not this body’. She could well relate to the fact that despite the abuse she had had, and how her body had changed from childhood to youth to now in her 30’s, she herself remained distinct, and constant, and Suzy was prepared to accept this as her ‘soul’. The next Vedic Teaching that the soul is not damaged by processes that damage the body, or even the mind was particularly healing for Suzy.

While the characteristics of the body made of material elements are that it ages, becomes in one way or another diseased, and eventually dies, the characteristics of the soul are sat, cit, and ananda vigraha   meaning eternal, full of cognizance, and joyfulness/peace.

Suzy realized that rather than concentrating on the ills of her body, and perceived distress in her mind, if she focused on further understanding and realizing the nature of her soul, she had an optimistic future. So empowered she felt that another working trip on the liner became a prospect for her.

Comments

  • Savita Bhandari

    December 02, 2009

    The fact is that we are body, mind and soul. so before there was medicine, or evidence based medicine, or science as man has classified it, there was a super science that created the universe,animals and plants. and so perhaps this is what it means - knowledge that works- the vedas. i have not read the vedas, but i have read parts of the Bhagvat Gita, the word of Krishna, and have more to learn, everyday. if we can keep an open mind and allow that which will come to us, in whatever form, a talk, a chat, a consultation form a medical GP like Dr Heena, it will allow healing on many levels. we dont have to be categorised as a qualified GP or pharmacist, and so only give a consultation relating to the knowledge we recieve from a university, but draw from relevant knowledge gained in life.

  • Julie Anne Meadows

    October 14, 2009

    We are more than our physical selves. If more people understood this then life on planet earth would be more tolerable for the majority. Healing the whole - heals all. Dr Patel's approach may not appeal to our Western "science" based limiting philosophy but it is a starting point of reference from which to understand that all is energy and energy is changing all the time. I look forward to the day when Mental Health embraces the concepts which Dr Patel verbalises as a specific "spiritual" doctrine. If Dr Patel had treated me during the dark night of the soul which sought to sink me, perhaps I could have saved 20 years' worth of self-discovery; then again we are here to experience the experience no matter how unpleasant for ourselves and others so those who survive may serve and teach.

  • Mark

    August 20, 2009

    I'm sure you're very good at what you do but personally I wouldn't choose to be treated by you. I like my doctors to be rational and scientific. You say "medicinal knowledge that works to ensure longevity is called Ayur Veda" which would indicate that you place evidence based methods and non evidence based methods of treatment on a par. I draw this conclusion because it's not medicinal knowledge: it is not medicine. I guess it could be a poor choice of words, but I would expect a doctor to be comfortable with drawing the distinction between medecine and non-evidence based treatments. Whether or not the counselling this girl recieved was of benefit to her, how can you argue that it was appropriate for you, in your role as GP, to be offering such a service?

  • Hari Kumar B Nair

    March 19, 2009

    Simply great and a classical example of Transcultural exchange of the phenomenology of life! Transcending above the body, and even the body-mind dichotomy to a more sublime `atman ` has been found helpful here.The question is how to account for this with science, and does science permit the "Soul" in Medicine?

  • Frances McGarraghy

    March 03, 2009

    Very interesting, I don't want to live long life, but a healthy one, so I'm going to study this Ayur Veda on the internet Google a good place to start. Thank you.